Peyton Manning the Best?

[Corso312]

Rg3 is a pocket passer...just fast as fuck....with all the rule changes and penalties for even breathing. On a qb now...ill take rg3 n Russ Wilson over luck.

 

[Mindmelted]

The Colts are obviously FAR better off. Andrew Luck is incredible. Dont they have like 10 wins this year? Think they had 2 last year? Folks in Indy I'm sure are like "Peyton who??"

Yeah 2 wins without peyton!

Compare apples with apples.

 

[Marley15]

Peyton Manning is the most fundamentally sound quarterback the NFL has ever seen.

 

[st0wandgrow]

Peyton Manning is the most fundamentally sound quarterback the NFL has ever seen.

Not sure how sound his fundamentals are, but I would say he's one of the smartest QB's ever, and is certainly one of the best leaders to ever play in the NFL.

He is the Wayne Gretzky of the football world, imo. His physical skills are average at best, but he thinks the game better than anyone else on the field.

 

[ClaytonBigsby]

I didn't think Luck would be that good that fast. Colts fans must be very happy. I don't think SBs are the only basis for judging a QB. How many SB wins did Marino have? Zero. Favre? 1. Great QBs

 

[Corso312]

Farve was very good but without that 225 consecutive game iron man streak he would be less thought of...Rodgers is already better than farce...so is Manning and Brady...probably Eli too.

 

[BadDog40]

I would love nothing more than the Pats having to come to Denver and get shellacked while the crowd continiously throws dog shit at McDaniels.

 

[bob Sanchez]

Rg3 is way to arrogant for my taste... Indianapolis is perfect for Luck...Rg3 would've brought to much baggage to Indy with his crap that he's started with the league already...Twice... Act alittle more like Luck...Keep your mouth shut and do your job...He acts like he's been in the league for years and it's his right to do and say what he wants...That's fine good and well...We just don't need that shit in Indy...Goodluck this week with the Seahawks...It's not the Romo show your gonna face this week... Just remember your 1 good hit away from the bench... Go Seahawks

 

[bob Sanchez]

Rodgers line blows...he is not good ..he is the best in the world for three years running...give him a hof. Wideout like rice or Harrison...or Wayne n you see even greater...that why I like Brady...he had an old moss for two years n killed it...lets see what Manning does in the playoffs...history has shown he wets the bed.

Manning is Marino with a ring...It's like watching the Chicago Cubs always a let down...Who'd you beat Sexy Rexy

 

[DukeOfDenver]

Peyton is ONE OF THE GREATEST LEADERS I've seen in a while. They are going to the motherfucking bowl and I'll be there smoking bowls!

 

[jjfw]

Peyton is a leader, for sure. My money is on Denver. They're healthy, hot and on a roll. ! week to heal the bumps and bruises, and it's Peyton time. Team player, John Fox lets him do it all, not to many that can do that today, just a few. Elway knew what he was doing and getting, another super bowl ring, as a owner.

 

[rooky1985]

while i do agree with this to an extent, i feel rodgers has a better d...i also think rodgers would be ALOT better if he had better or different receivers.


and rodgers still has to prove ''eliteness'' to me, anyone can be good for 3 or 4 years, it takes many years of being great to be considered in talks with montana, IMO

Better defense than denver? points per game denver is in top 5 last two seasons.

 

[rooky1985]

Denver is a safe bet, but does it bother you denver fans that his little brother has two rings after lucking in to the playoffs. I want to bet on a Rookie QB this year but I will loose some $$$$. Anyone think the colts made a mistake by not re-signing Him?

 

[Corso312]

Does Manning even have more tds than picks in the post season? Rodgers> Manning...not even close.

 

[fb360]

IMO, Peyton is the coolest kat in the position currently. He is cool, calm, and collected with a football in his hands. If he is not the best qb currently, he is certainly one of the best. I do also highly respect Brees, Rodgers, Brady and even Ryan.

 

[Corso312]

If he is so cool then why a huge dropoff in stats from the reg season to post season when competition increases?

 

[fb360]

If he is so cool then why a huge dropoff in stats from the reg season to post season when competition increases?

The post seasons are about good teams vs good teams. Indy hasn't been exactly known as the most talented team. It is clear that he is a cool kat by the way he utterly controls and effectively manipulates his offense; more so than any other qb in the league. Give Peyton Manning Calvin Johnson and Larry Fitzgerald and it wouldn't be fair for any defense.

 

[Corso312]

Lol...you think Rodgers n Brady have those guys? They don't..they just throw less picks n more tds...their red zones numbers are sick...Harrison,Clark,Wayne n garcon better than any crew Rodgers or Brady had.

 

[jjfw]

Stats? Stat's don't mean shit, now. Bronco Fever, man , have to wait another week, for the Orange Crush, I hope John Elway leads the team out of the tunnel, with the Bronco Flag, right, Place would go insane for sure.

 

[OGEvilgenius]

Peyton Manning is the most fundamentally sound quarterback the NFL has ever seen.

Unquestionably.