If Medicare is better than private insurance...

abandonconflict

Well-Known Member
I thought Robert Reich was an economist.

Someone should tell him that $738B $32T because he's not even close.

He's only off by about 31.2 trillion dollars though.
 

Padawanbater2

Well-Known Member
3 trillion

Ensuring everyone has coverage is $3 trillion less than what we currently pay for healthcare that fails to cover 30 million Americans

That also ensures they have dental, eye, and ear coverage, too, and they're not forced to stay at a job they don't like, or stay in a relationship they don't like just to keep coverage, like they currently do. It also ensures they're not rationing medication or paying hundreds of times more than they should to buy necessary medication like insulin
 

Fogdog

Well-Known Member
What does that even mean? So what if we spend x dollars on defense and y dollars on healthcare? They are spent on completely different objectives. Would it make sense to just cut healthcare willy nilly to pay for more bombs? Cutting defense spending is a completely different topic. Old Bob conflated to cost of military defense with healthcare costs in order to justify spending more on one or the other. What he just did is tells us age has caught up with them.
 

Communist Dreamer

Well-Known Member
3 trillion

Ensuring everyone has coverage is $3 trillion less than what we currently pay for healthcare that fails to cover 30 million Americans

That also ensures they have dental, eye, and ear coverage, too, and they're not forced to stay at a job they don't like, or stay in a relationship they don't like just to keep coverage, like they currently do. It also ensures they're not rationing medication or paying hundreds of times more than they should to buy necessary medication like insulin
Is this going to add hearing to Medicare which currently doesn't? Or is it just like now, "yeah, our tests say you're deaf, that'll be $3,000 per ear, out of pocket, all on you, we won't pay jack!"

That's what I was told with Blue Cross, after paying $20 for the referral, and $35 for the specialist.
 

Padawanbater2

Well-Known Member
Is this going to add hearing to Medicare which currently doesn't? Or is it just like now, "yeah, our tests say you're deaf, that'll be $3,000 per ear, out of pocket, all on you, we won't pay jack!"

That's what I was told with Blue Cross, after paying $20 for the referral, and $35 for the specialist.
No cost at the point of service for health, dental, eye, or hearing, like other modern first world countries
 

Fogdog

Well-Known Member
No cost at the point of service for health, dental, eye, or hearing, like other modern first world countries
3 trillion

Ensuring everyone has coverage is $3 trillion less than what we currently pay for healthcare that fails to cover 30 million Americans

That also ensures they have dental, eye, and ear coverage, too, and they're not forced to stay at a job they don't like, or stay in a relationship they don't like just to keep coverage, like they currently do. It also ensures they're not rationing medication or paying hundreds of times more than they should to buy necessary medication like insulin
You aren't going to pay for that. We know this already.

Where, in his healthcare bill, does Bernie spell out who pays and how much it will be?

Bernie should put some sort of "actual mileage may vary" label in his bill. Guessing that costs and disclaimers were in the other half of that bill that wasn't part of his submission to Congress. Bernie must have forgotten.
 

Communist Dreamer

Well-Known Member
No cost at the point of service for health, dental, eye, or hearing, like other modern first world countries
Like I said, just for the hearing test, or the hearing aid too? Because Costco for the $60 membership fee gave me the same news, but wanted $2,500 per ear.

This is what Medicare says, so what you say doesn't seem true with your M4A plan?
Things to know
Medicare doesn’t cover hearing exams, hearing aids, or exams for fitting hearing aids.

 

Padawanbater2

Well-Known Member
Like I said, just for the hearing test, or the hearing aid too? Because Costco for the $60 membership fee gave me the same news, but wanted $2,500 per ear.

This is what Medicare says, so what you say doesn't seem true with your M4A plan?
Things to know
Medicare doesn’t cover hearing exams, hearing aids, or exams for fitting hearing aids.

Everything. It's an expansion of Medicare that covers everyone, not just 65+
 

abandonconflict

Well-Known Member
3 trillion

Ensuring everyone has coverage is $3 trillion less than what we currently pay
That's a great idea. We should ensure everyone has coverage.

You should read about "Medicare for all who want it". Mayor Pete thinks it can be done for 1.5 trillion dollars in the first decade. That would be mostly paid for simply by repealing the Trump tax cuts to the rich.
 

Padawanbater2

Well-Known Member
That's a great idea. We should ensure everyone has coverage.

You should read about "Medicare for all who want it". Mayor Pete thinks it can be done for 1.5 trillion dollars in the first decade. That would be mostly paid for simply by repealing the Trump tax cuts to the rich.
It's already been explained to you how a system like Buttigieg is proposing fails from inception by having no way to fund the public part of the program as "those that want it" are poor people who can't afford private insurance and those that can won't subsidize the public option. You still haven't addressed that.

The new part is somehow getting a Republican held Senate to overturn the Trump tax cuts they just voted in in 2017, a virtual impossibility
 

abandonconflict

Well-Known Member
It's already been explained to you how a system like Buttigieg is proposing fails from inception by having no way to fund the public part of the program as "those that want it" are poor people who can't afford private insurance and those that can won't subsidize the public option. You still haven't addressed that.
Actually, I did. Your conclusion doesn't follow from your premise. You see, it's an expansion of medicare. Those uninsured or under-insured who want medicare will have it. Then they'll be covered. This expense will be then picked up by the federal budget. Everyone else can then keep their private plan. For example, I take a small tax hike (as opposed to that sanders idea where I give up two thirds of my income) and then I continue to provide myself with private insurance.

Let me know if I used too many big words.
 

abandonconflict

Well-Known Member
Meaning taxes go up, spending goes down, or debts are accrued

So does Buttigieg plan on raising taxes, cutting spending, or increasing the debt/deficit to pay for his "Medicare for all who want it" plan?
The first two, not the third.

Unlike Bernie who promises the world and has no plan for how to pay for it.
 

Communist Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Actually, I did. Your conclusion doesn't follow from your premise. You see, it's an expansion of medicare. Those uninsured or under-insured who want medicare will have it. Then they'll be covered. This expense will be then picked up by the federal budget. Everyone else can then keep their private plan. For example, I take a small tax hike (as opposed to that sanders idea where I give up two thirds of my income) and then I continue to provide myself with private insurance.

Let me know if I used too many big words.
If you don't like it, why don't you cut ties with America completely? Isn't that how you guys work? "Don't like it leave!" Well, you left, and are almost there.

Unless you have a student loan debt, just go up to any one of America's stronghold's, a consulate, and tell an official, "My name is Abondonconflict, and I renounce my citizenship." They'll try to convince you otherwise for about 15 minutes while they make you sign a few papers. Other than that, it's super easy.

Also, they won't really get rid of your citizenship completely, so you don't have to worry. If America finally becomes your own fanatical Utopia, just later come back and say you've changed your mind. They've always done it in the past.

But I personally think you're just a drama queen.

No more unfair American abroad taxes.
 

abandonconflict

Well-Known Member
If you don't like it, why don't you cut ties with America completely? Isn't that how you guys work? "Don't like it leave!" Well, you left, and are almost there.

Unless you have a student loan debt, just go up to any one of America's stronghold's, a consulate, and tell an official, "My name is Abondonconflict, and I renounce my citizenship." They'll try to convince you otherwise for about 15 minutes while they make you sign a few papers. Other than that, it's super easy.

Also, they won't really get rid of your citizenship completely, so you don't have to worry. If America finally becomes your own fanatical Utopia, just later come back and say you've changed your mind. They've always done it in the past.

But I personally think you're just a drama queen.

No more unfair American abroad taxes.
Nah, nothing you said interests me at all.

How about you try not to get chased out of anymore playgrounds by mothers. Personally, if it was me dealing with creeps like you getting too close to other people's kids, I'd have probably really harmed you.
 
Top