You ever notice TeaTree has a link to a whole thread with a buch of drawings about how his little grow room could operate better than a 400w HPS light?
Where's the grow journal TeaTree? No Links to grow logs huh? No Youtube videos that you've created showing superior results with your theory's? Stop reading and start TRYING, you'll find out why you're a lone voice. Something doesn't work right and HID's grow faster, stronger, plants with greater yeilds in less time.
If you want to continue to have discussions and to progress CFL's why do you keep talking to us and telling us why you think CFL's SHOULD be better. They aren't better, so something is missing. Spend your time telling us what is wrong with CFL's and where they are lacking so that we can all colaborate and discuss solutions instead of your mostly useless banter about PAR and LUX when obviously those things aren't the key to growing MJ.