Agreed. HPS will work great, as long as you don't have it too close. Keep it about 26" away and they wil do fine. You didn't mention if they were rooted or not? If they are already rooted, you can bring the light down closer, like 18"-20". And after they've been rooted for about a week, they can handle quite a bit of light. You should be able to run that light at 14-16" and as long as it's not too hot for them, they'll grow nice and short, with close internode spacing. A MH bulb will work good too, but i prefer the extra output of the HPS bulb, over the spectrum of the MH. Get an HPS bulb that is 'color balanced' with extra blue added and you'll be happier with it, than the MH. The better spectrum of the MH simply does not outweigh the extra lumens on the HPS, so the HPS is the better choice. I tested this myself, and was surprised with the results. As long as you have the distance correct so that you're up over approx 3200 lumens per square foot, stretching won't be an issue for either type of light, but the HPS will give you a little more area of coverage.