@
johnnytsmitw Yeah... pyrethrins are organic. So are all the little microbes and bacteria in my organic soil that do all sorts of good things for my plant. I personally wouldn't want to use it in my soil. It also has such a short half life(hence it's appeal) but this means that it is only killing the larvae in your soil. Not the gnats, not the eggs. That's why it's probably not working very well. You really need an IGR to fuck with their ability to reproduce. Considering money is a problem I would NOT be surprised if you ended up spending the same amount if not more on the pyrethrins route because you will have to use it constantly.
@growne There is no reason in you buying organic soil if you are going to sterilize it. Pretty sure organic soils are by definition non-sterile because they have all sorts of microbes creating the nutrients. That's why organic fertilizers have such low NPK ratings, their nutrients are in non-available forms until the microbes change them. If you are using organic fertilizers you are just cheating yourself, and if you are not then you are simply paying way too much for soil. If you are looking for a nice organic soil I recommend fox farm ocean forest. I have never gotten any nasties in it, although it prolly does cost a little more.