First off, I prefer organic weed. I can taste a difference. When I grow outdoor, I grow organic. I've grown many live soil indoor grows, as well.
Weed grown with chem nutes should not taste like chemicals. Many growers jam nutes down the plants throat and never flush. This would result in a poor tasting product. It doesn't have to be this way. Properly grown and flushed, chem plants can taste absolutely wonderful, with zero residual chemical flavor. The real difference between a live soil organic plant and a properly grown chem plant is complexity of flavor and smell. The organic plant just has more complexity. It's like the difference between a pasta dish made with 5 ingredients and a pasta dish made with 10 ingredients. Both dishes could taste absolutely wonderful. In fact, both dishes could be world class. But...the 10 ingredient dish will have more flavors working and will therefore have a more complex taste. An organic plant is much the same. But, there's nothing to keep you from growing world class weed with chemical nutrients.
We will soom be testing various liquid organic nutes, and there effect on flavor. I will be trying to determine if that organic complexity can be had without actual live soil. Can we use refined organic nutes to give us that organic flavor in, say, a sterile rockwool media? Can we use 300-500ppm chemical base nute and another 500-700ppm organic nutes to produce organic flavored weed? Basically, can we have the control and predictability of chemicals with the outcome of organics? Or, is it the "live soil" component that provides that organic kick? The next question is naturally, can we generate a micro-herd in rockwool and grow live soil in the Hugo Blocks? I will attempt to answer all of these questions over the next year or so. I would invite other growers to help me and participate.
That all being said, Beansly, large commercial ops are easiest to run using chemical nutes. Actual live soil would be a nightmare in an operation my size. I'm sure you can produce some outstanding buds using chemical nutes. In the end, it's still strain strain strain that determines 95% of the quality of your smoke. The grower determines how much of it you get. Granted, you can fuck up the quality, but it's still imperative you start with killer genetics. Not anything you can order online...for the most part.
With all that being said, if you feel strong toward growing organic, I would be the last person to talk you out of it. Shit, I want to buy some. If you are comfortable growing live soil in a good sized grow, fucking do it, Killer. I'm sure with sound planning and layout you could design an op that keeps the mess to a minimum. If you have the skills to make a live soil grow produce great yields, and don't mind the mess, you should do it. I know I'm supposed to be talking you into chemicals. Sorry.