What if it's the Palestinians who are the REAL Hebrews from the religious books?

Legalize Nature

Active Member
It sounds crazy, as we've always been raised up to link Hebrew with Jew. But, there have been genetic tests (done in Israel) which discovered that the Palestinians are actually Jews, genetically. I watched a clip on Youtube called "The Hidden Palestinian Jew", which is in Hebrew w/ English subtitles and originally aired on Israeli TV. It has quotes from Israel's founders and first prime ministers, who after immigrating to the land 100 years ago, began to believe that the Palestinians were the Hebrew farmers that stayed on the land, and were forced to convert *to Islam after the Muslim Arabs invaded in the 7th century. It does kinda make sense, bc the Egyptians (who are today Arab) built pyramids before accepting Islam and speaking Arabic, Iraqis are Mesopotamians before becoming Arabized.

The common thinking is that all the Hebrew Jews were kicked off the land by the 2nd Century and sent to exile, but there is not 1 single research book on this subject, and almost all serious historians, Israeli or not, consider it false.

I don't understand why people don't talk about this that much? Even the Wiki page on "Palestinian People" says they're descended from Jews. Israel is founded on the Hebrews coming back to their homeland, so it's very relevant, as Palestinians being in the center of their genetics means they also have that right according to Zionism.. Plus their Torah promises it to the Hebrew BLOODLINE, not the Jewish RELIGION. So them kicking fellow Hebrews off the land is a major sin for them.

What are your opinions?*


EDIT
===============

Here is the video.

@ 2:00 - They're quoting Israeli founding fathers, David Ben Gurion and Yitzak Ben Zvi, who would become Israel's first and second prime ministers.

@ 5:00 - A geneticist from Israel's best University, Hebrew University, talks about her findings, and how Palestinians are in the center of Jewish genetics.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z03FR-JzRug
 

Legalize Nature

Active Member
This shouldn't be in the politics section.

Why not? The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is political. Even if this were only an American political forum, it would still be relevant, as we give Israel 3 billion dollars of tax payers money a year... More than any other nation on Earth. Do the math... That's 12k for every Israeli thanks to our taxes. Americans should understand the conflict as best they can, seeing as we're pouring truck loads of our precious dollars over there.
 

NoDrama

Well-Known Member
Why not? The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is political. Even if this was only an American political forum, it would still be relevant, as we give Israel 3 billion dollars of tax payers money a year... More than any other nation on Earth. Do the math... That's 12k for every Israeli thanks to our taxes.
Don't worry, we will just get a mod to move it to the Religion section. It will still exist and you will probably get a lot more views and discussion there.
 

UncleBuck

Well-Known Member
and i won't have to deal with looking at a thread about "self hating jews" or whatever the hell this is bound to be about.

just going off what little research i did googling about this.
 

fenderburn84

Well-Known Member
Right on man. If you start a thread somewhere else we can jaw it for awhile. But its a special time of year with some big shit goin on, and this talk is a troll magnet.
 

cannofbliss

Well-Known Member
cannofbliss remembered and said aloud... "ahh crap i left my hat back there..."

moments later... cannofbliss arrives back to the house of where the threadius judeacious maximus offencivicus is located..

and cannofbliss gingerly and cautiously types...

"ohh... sorry i had to come back... i ummm... left my hat over there on the couch... gotta go again bye..."
 

jdillinger

Active Member
Everyones titled to their opinion. At the end of the day its the opinions of the affected people and what stake they have. I've been to Israel on a pilgrimage with my family, back maybe... 10 years? Its pretty cool, the american media exaggerates everything, jews and muslims and christians get along fine. Well from my week stay, there was no tension only like forboding security checkpoints within jerusalem, but I wasn't there the whole time.

I REALLY DO WONDER! Why can't they all just get along? I don't understand all these extremists (on both sides). But I guess I never will, I'm in no position to judge. Anybody with no stake just seems its being so stupid.
 

fenderburn84

Well-Known Member
No uncle buck, this issue is about a people, we all know how this ends. In political season, we in the US have much more important to discuss than the bloodlines of two tribes. It really is not political, all this is going to do is turn into a heated argument that everyone will say has no place here, and I promise will lead to a bunch of new sigs for nodrama lol.
 

budlover13

King Tut
While i believe that there are some political aspects to this discussion, i also believe that this belongs in the Spirituality forum. i've never moved a thread but i will see what i can do.
 
Top