I wouldn't be using the heater but had it and figured better to use it than not. The water comes out of the tap extra cold in the winter, the basement is kinda frigid. I bring the temp up to 68-72F. I did read the book: Teaming with Microges: The Organic Gardener's Buide to the Soil Food Web by Jeff Lowenfels, and highly recommend it!!! I also have been vermicomposting for the past couple years and recommend that as well, easy to maintain and really concentrated compost.
Related to the questions about temperature control here is and excerpt from the above mentioned book:
"Temperature is important when brewing compost teas. If it is too cold, microbial activity slows. If temperatures get too high, then the microbes are literally cooked or go dormant. Room temperature is ideal. Keep track of the water temperature. This is one of the variables you can adjust later, if need be, and a record of this information will be helpful to the lab testing your samples. If you cannot site your brewer in a warm place with steady temperatures, then a small, inexpensive aquarium heater might be needed; these come with automatic thermostats."