Do People Have The Right To Organize And Shut Down Town Hall Discussion?

is it a constitutional right to actively organize and shut down town hall discussion

  • Yes, it's their right.

    Votes: 21 51.2%
  • No, it's not their right.

    Votes: 18 43.9%
  • Not sure.

    Votes: 2 4.9%

  • Total voters
    41
Status
Not open for further replies.

NoDrama

Well-Known Member
I sincerely hope your comments are laced with a heavy amount of sarcasm. The very fact that I cannot discern is troubling.

SEE!! JRH gets my point exactly!

The thread title says it all, only stupid people care about their rights.
 
K

Keenly

Guest
it really is a stupid thread topic

do stupid people have the right....


that is a dark path your going down when you start picking and choosing who gets what rights.... pretty prejudice, and just plain selfish
 

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
probably because rational discussion is not allowed. when you shut down the only forum that you can express your opinion then EVERYONE is SILENCED. why cant anyone grasp this?

any rational argument which could be presented against this healthcare reform is silenced along with those who oppose it.

when you actively shut down the forum this is what happens. the plan goes along anyway and nobody gets to argue it. and why? so a group of fucking retards can scream "JUST SAY NO!!!! JUST SAY NO!!!! JUST SAY NO!!!", intimidate everyone, and shut down all discussion.

Here's a rational argument against "mandatory free healthcare" . It's mandatory, we are not subjects are we? It's not free. Government will fuck it up.
Care to refute any of that?
 

PVS

Active Member
Here's a rational argument against "mandatory free healthcare" . It's mandatory, we are not subjects are we? It's not free. Government will fuck it up.
Care to refute any of that?
refute what? your opinion on proposed healthcare specs or psychic prediction that the "government will fuck it up"? really i don't give a shit. its not the topic anyway.
 

PVS

Active Member
Just because the majority of people who WENT to the town hall meetings may be against it doesn't mean that the majority of ALL americans are against it. Two very different things.
its sad that you have to explain this and even more sad that he still won't understand.
 

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
refute what? your opinion on proposed healthcare specs or psychic prediction that the "government will fuck it up"? really i don't give a shit. its not the topic anyway.
So you conveniently ignore the mandatory part eh? That's okay, most refuse to see or discuss the obvious.

My pyschic prediction? That's funny. You think more government is needed? How the fuck did inflation get started? Multi trillion dollar debt? Wars? Drug prohibition? Our government imprisons more people percentage wise than any other country and you want MORE government?

The topic was town hall stuff, ignorant people etc. I agree ignorant people should have the right to an opinion, they do not have a right to use government take my liberty away though.
 

OregonMeds

Well-Known Member
I agree ignorant people should have the right to an opinion, they do not have a right to use government take my liberty away though.
They can if they have over 50% of the votes or if they can fake having over 50%. I seem to recall having some of my liberties taken away recently when some number of idiots voted for baby Bush and he shoved a patriot act up our asses.

Same thing happened before many times for example like prohibition both alcohol and other...
 

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
They can if they have over 50% of the votes. I seem to recall having some of my liberties taken away recently when over 50% of the idiots voted for baby Bush and he shoved a patriot act up our asses.

Same thing happened before many times for example like prohibition both alcohol and other...
So two wrongs make a right? The Patriot Act was voted in by alot of Republicans and Democrats. All of them were wrong.
The Patriot Act is an affront to liberty.
So is mandatory healthcare.

A majority vote does not ensure correctness or morality. Often times a majority vote can take liberty and create more victimless crimes...pot for example.
 

OregonMeds

Well-Known Member
I never agreed with the patriot act nor any of the other thousands of things that have taken away liberties except socialized health care I do support, I believe it's in everyone and the countries best interests as a whole.

Saying it's not is like saying we shouldn't have public schools. An educated public is no more important than a healthy one, you need both for maximum productivity.

I'm not at all a fan of this health care bill, I would have chosen one exactly like france with no insurance companies and NO PROFIT as a part of it just let them die, but I will support this health care plan just to start in a new direction.
 

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
I never agreed with the patriot act nor any of the other thousands of things that have taken away liberties except socialized health care I do support, I believe it's in everyone and the countries best interests as a whole.

Saying it's not is like saying we shouldn't have public schools. An educated public is no more important than a healthy one, you need both for maximum productivity.

I'm not at all a fan of this health care bill, I would have chosen one exactly like france with no insurance companies and NO PROFIT as a part of it just let them die, but I will support this health care plan just to start in a new direction.
Okay...we shouldn't have public schools.
They too are funded under the threat of violence. Perhaps the kids should be made aware of this?
 

Big P

Well-Known Member
guys guys you look at the polls to see who got the majorty of the people on thier side.


this pollster was the closest one during the election

so here is your proof ladies:weed:

Rasmussen:
53% Now Oppose Congressional Health Care Reform


http://harvest.AdGardener.com/noscript.aspx?s=91&c=c7c32c55-5525-46d7-a124-a5aa5613eca3

The health care reform legislation working its way through Congress has lost support over the past month. The latest Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey shows that 44% of U.S. voters are at least somewhat in favor of the reform effort while 53% are at least somewhat opposed.
Today’s 44% level of support is down from 46% two weeks ago, and 50% in late June.

Opposition has grown from 45% in late June to 49% two weeks ago and 53% today.

As in earlier surveys, those with strong opinions are more likely to oppose the plan rather than support it. The current numbers: 24% strongly favor and 37% strongly oppose.

(Want a free daily e-mail update? If it's in the news, it's in our polls). Rasmussen Reports updates are also available on Twitter.
There is a huge partisan divide on the health care plan. Sixty-eight percent (68%) of Democrats favor it. However, the plan is opposed by 80% of Republicans and 60% of those not affiliated with either major party.

Most voters who earn less than $40,000 annually favor the legislation. Most who earn more than that amount are opposed. Premium Memberscan see full demographic crosstabs.

The survey question did not in any way describe the plan as it stands to date. It was simply presented as “the health care reform plan proposed by President Obama and congressional Democrats.” But public opinion could shift in either direction as details of the plan become clearer and if agreement is reached.

The president has recently become more vocal in promoting the plan as opposition from senators and congressmen in his own party have stalled it on Capitol Hill. He will host a prime time press conference tonight to push the legislation which he had hoped would be passed by both the Senate and House before they leave for their August recess at the end of next week.

One reason for the decline in support may be the legislative emphasis on universal coverage rather than cost controls. Voters see cost, not universal coverage, as the biggest health care concern. Also, 78% believe that health care reform is likely to lead to middle class tax hikes. Figuring out how to pay for the trillion dollar-plus plan has presented a significant challenge for congressional Democrats working on the legislation.

Another factor that may be playing a role is underlying public skepticism about the legislative process. Americans, by a two-to-one margin, believe that no matter how bad things are, Congress can always make it worse.
Despite the declining support for the plan proposed by the president and congressional Democrats, 51% of voters say it’s at least somewhat likely that it will be passed this year. That figure includes 17% who say it’s very likely to pass.

Overall, just 35% of Americans rate the U.S. health care system as good or excellent.But 70% of those who have health insurance rate their own coverage as good or excellent.

One key item in the overall debate is a government health insurance company that would compete with private insurers. Thirty-five percent (35%) of voters favor a public health care option while 50% are opposed.
Please sign up for the Rasmussen Reports daily e-mail update (it’s free) or follow us on Twitter. Let us keep you up to date with the latest public opinion news.
See survey questions and toplines. Crosstabs are available to Premium Members only.
ShareThis
 

hanimmal

Well-Known Member
here is an example (do not take this to the extreme because i am not speaking of a "death panel")


an 80 year old "relatively" healthy man gets diagnosed with a cancer of some kind

there is medicine and treatment available that has the ability to prolong his life an addition 6 months to a year beyond his expected expiration time

they would also send him to some "acceptance" and "getting ready for death" counseling like they have been mentioning



the doctor would not provide care to this man, as he is 80 years old (going to die anyway) as to cut costs, and save the treatment for a younger, healthier person


and as for your statement, i do hate obama, but i let him make his reputation on his own, and lie after lie, i continue to dislike the man more and more
But this is all bullshit! There is nothing that says that is how it is going to happen. What the hell do you think medicare is?

Hell my 78 year old grandmother is in the hospital right now from a triple bypass heart surgery.
 

hanimmal

Well-Known Member
Keeny Wrote:
once again, i read the bill, stop being childish telling me to do something i already did....again

cost sharing reffers to what you, as well as the government, and insurance company (as your co payers)

there is a LIMIT on your cost sharing

like i said, 5k$ for individuals and 10K$ for families

once you set a limit for a service, you are rationing that service....

its the very definition of the word ration....
Then Londonfog wrote:
Page 29: Admission: your health care will be rationed! False: Section 122 outlines broad categories of benefits that must be included in an essential benefits package. It prohibits cost-sharing for preventive care and limits annual out-of-pocket spending to $5,000 for an individual and $10,000 for a family, indexed for inflation. It says nothing about rationing or limiting treatment.

take the time to read
And you just ignore it. If you are not a republican plant, you are the next best thing to one.
 

Operation 420

Well-Known Member
Saying it's not is like saying we shouldn't have public schools. An educated public is no more important than a healthy one, you need both for maximum productivity.
Our education system is horrible. Are you actually trying to make a point by bringing that up? Are you going to bring up the swell job the post office is doing too?
 

NoDrama

Well-Known Member
Schools are mandatory so that children can be indoctrinated into American culture of the herd mentality. Told history that didn't really happen because if you told it like it is people would be shocked and horrified. Children are never taught how money and the fiat dollar really works in school, they have to figure it out for themselves. Our levels of math and reading comprehension have been in decline for decades, actually it started declining when Government got too involved and started taking more and more control over the education system. Money wasted as they have had to dumb down everything they teach to the lowest common denominator. Its no wonder only 23% of graduating seniors have the skills necessary to succeed in college.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top