Dyna-Gro vs Advanced Nutrients Connoisseur (AK47 Grow)

joe macclennan

Well-Known Member
So at what EC do you recommend running the foliage pro at in veg? running f&d hydroton.

straight ro water.

Magpro or no?

I appreciate you sharing your experience with us.
 

homebrewer

Well-Known Member
So at what EC do you recommend running the foliage pro at in veg? running f&d hydroton.

straight ro water.

Magpro or no?

I appreciate you sharing your experience with us.
I just started experimenting with it in hydro and due to the higher amount of N, I've cut the EC back by 15%. So if you were using 'grow' at 1.0 EC, try .85EC with foliage pro. I'm still figuring some things out so if you have any input or discoveries, feel free to share.

I am still using a dash of magpro but also scaled back by 15% or so.
 

djwimbo

Well-Known Member
Please forgive me for not reading all of this, but I have a quick question, and a general answer would be acceptable. I'd PM you, but I feel the open part of the forum would benefit.

If we're talking Dyna Gro nutes, have you tried the Hi-N-Pro? I know you mentioned using the Grow more than anything, just curious if you have tested both, or if it's even worthwhile.
 

homebrewer

Well-Known Member
Please forgive me for not reading all of this, but I have a quick question, and a general answer would be acceptable. I'd PM you, but I feel the open part of the forum would benefit.

If we're talking Dyna Gro nutes, have you tried the Hi-N-Pro? I know you mentioned using the Grow more than anything, just curious if you have tested both, or if it's even worthwhile.
I've not messed with high N pro, not sure if I will since foliage pro's 9-3-6 isn't too far off from 10-5-5.
 

joe macclennan

Well-Known Member
The only thing I can say with certainty is that I am really liking the results of running the 7-9-5 for the first 4 weeks of flower. I have been running a 30/70 mix of well water/ro that gets my ec to less than .4. I am going to go 100% ro starting next week.

This last rez. change I mixed in 25% 7-9-5 into my second stage rez in flower and made the balance up with 3-12-6.Next rez. change I will prob. go 50/50 bloom/grow for rez 2.

I have also been running 2ml/gallon magpro and 2ml/gallon protekt in flower and veg. Which I am suspecting is too much in relation to the foliage pro, and to a lesser extent the grow.

I am showing what seems to be a zinc def. in veg now. I am not 100% on this though as the symptoms don't EXACTLY match the pics I have found online. It seems that no matter where you look deff. symptoms up they all use the same stock photos.

This last rez. change I cut out the magpro entirely and cut my protekt in half in veg. I made the balance up with the 9-3-6. This was yesterday tho so I don't know if this was good or bad yet.

I should add that I am just coming out of a major fungus gnat infestation and I caught some root aphids before they got out of control.
I got rid of the aphids with an imid drench in veg. about three weeks ago and have been drenching with gnatrol 2x a week since for the gnats so some root damage is present on the older plants that I am sure is causing some of the symptoms I am seeing.

Some of the recently transplanted clones were also starting to show def. symptoms prior to my rez change yesterday though so I am wondering if using too much of the magpro was locking out zinc. As the magpro is super high in p. I am just guessing here tho.


The gnats are damn near gone and I haven't seen an aphid in two weeks. I have some of the best roots I have seen busting out of the 10" netpots my moms are in and overall things are looking better than a month ago but I am still experimenting some in veg with the fol. pro.

If the def. symptoms don't start clearing up in veg. I'm gonna go back to the 7-9-5 I think next time.

Anyways, sorry for the absurdly long post but that's my story. :peace:
 

inhaleindica

Well-Known Member
The only thing I can say with certainty is that I am really liking the results of running the 7-9-5 for the first 4 weeks of flower. I have been running a 30/70 mix of well water/ro that gets my ec to less than .4. I am going to go 100% ro starting next week.

This last rez. change I mixed in 25% 7-9-5 into my second stage rez in flower and made the balance up with 3-12-6.Next rez. change I will prob. go 50/50 bloom/grow for rez 2.

I have also been running 2ml/gallon magpro and 2ml/gallon protekt in flower and veg. Which I am suspecting is too much in relation to the foliage pro, and to a lesser extent the grow.

I am showing what seems to be a zinc def. in veg now. I am not 100% on this though as the symptoms don't EXACTLY match the pics I have found online. It seems that no matter where you look deff. symptoms up they all use the same stock photos.

This last rez. change I cut out the magpro entirely and cut my protekt in half in veg. I made the balance up with the 9-3-6. This was yesterday tho so I don't know if this was good or bad yet.

I should add that I am just coming out of a major fungus gnat infestation and I caught some root aphids before they got out of control.
I got rid of the aphids with an imid drench in veg. about three weeks ago and have been drenching with gnatrol 2x a week since for the gnats so some root damage is present on the older plants that I am sure is causing some of the symptoms I am seeing.

Some of the recently transplanted clones were also starting to show def. symptoms prior to my rez change yesterday though so I am wondering if using too much of the magpro was locking out zinc. As the magpro is super high in p. I am just guessing here tho.


The gnats are damn near gone and I haven't seen an aphid in two weeks. I have some of the best roots I have seen busting out of the 10" netpots my moms are in and overall things are looking better than a month ago but I am still experimenting some in veg with the fol. pro.

If the def. symptoms don't start clearing up in veg. I'm gonna go back to the 7-9-5 I think next time.

Anyways, sorry for the absurdly long post but that's my story. :peace:
I too am experimenting with Foliage Pro in Veg only and I don't see any zinc def so far. I don't use Mag-pro at all so far, this is in Veg only. However, with FP I have to use a lot less protekt to balance the PH and little less FP than I would with grow since it burns my leaves a slight. Just like what HB said 15% less EC with FP should do the trick
 

homebrewer

Well-Known Member
I too am experimenting with Foliage Pro in Veg only and I don't see any zinc def so far. I don't use Mag-pro at all so far, this is in Veg only. However, with FP I have to use a lot less protekt to balance the PH and little less FP than I would with grow since it burns my leaves a slight. Just like what HB said 15% less EC with FP should do the trick
I agree, use it properly and you'll be deficiency-free. Water plays a big role though as sometimes unbalanced water out of the tap can lead us to believe that something is wrong with our plant food.
 

joe macclennan

Well-Known Member
Two days on fresh rez. foliage pro and around 1.2ml protekt/gallon, no magpro and no new deff. signs showing:weed: in veg.

Just the slightest bit of nitrogen abundance in flower showing at about week 3 where I am running grow7-9-5 with 2ml magpro and 2ml protekt. Plants are very dark. Almost a bit blue. Could be an early P deff. but I am not sure. All in all they look very Healthy though. I think I may mix a little bit of bloom in next time. Maybe 25% or so to try and fix what looks to be the P deff. Also gonna cut back the magpro to 1ml/gallon.

So it appears I was correct in thinking I was adding too much magpro in veg. Causing what looked to be a zinc deff.

I Am gonna have to mix in 10% well water this rez change tho cuz my new ro filter won't be here in time and I cannot make enough purified water to go 100% at this time.

I just can't say enough how pleased I am with the 7-9-5 for first month of flower. Virtually no nitro deff showing yet still good flower development.

+ rep to ya HB for the great thread.

EDIT: mixing a fresh rez. for my flowering moms now.

50 gallons total 10 wellwater/40 ro
7 oz grow7-9-5
5 oz bloom 3-12-6
2 oz protekt
1 oz magpro

final ec 1.2

10 inch netpots 1x flood/day
co2 enriched room.

we'll see :)
 

Alfonso

Member
That quote from page 63 is a pretty good place to start for veg. Moving into flower, I bump the EC just over 1.0-1.1 and feed with about 80% bloom and 20% grow. That small amount of grow seems to be enough to keep the plants green in my environment. I pretty much keep protekt where it was in veg moving into flower and also add some magpro. Since you're using tap water, magpro might not be necessary for you.

FWIW, I like the rockwool blocks from B'cuzz a little better than grodan cubes. They're both good products but the grodan cubes hold water longer than I'd like them too as they're a little more dense.
ive been searching your threads. Not sure if I missed this or not but I'm starting DIY ebb n flo using dyna gro grow , bloom, proteck. Can you help me out on a feeding schedule? I know it varies with strain to strain just need some base number to go off of and if I c it's on the high side ill make adjustments. My clones were started on Rockwell cubes and are now in 1 gal pots. Using tap water starting at 200ppm 8.0 ph. Currently under fluorescent for 2 week veg then to flower under 600whps. Currently top feeding as I'm not sure how many gal of a Rez I need. I was going to use a 30 gal barrel but it limits my height availability. Would I be ok with say a 20 gal Rubbermaid from homedepot?

what I mean for feeding schedule is for all stages of growth say for newly cut clones do u feed any or just plain phd water?
Rooted clones going into veg. Would I be okay starting at around 400ppm when my tap starts at 200? And progress from there? The ratio between grow/protect? No bloom?
in flower considering a two week veg I should be at around 500ppm or is that too high? 8-10week flower time. What should I be at around week 8? 900ppm? What ratio of bloom/grow/protect? Protect all the way through flower? I remember reading that you said that even though your plants aren't burning at say 1500ppm but they'll be much better off at 1000ppm( just an example) I want to feed as little as possible without seeing any deficiencies. Thank you for all your help
 

homebrewer

Well-Known Member
ive been searching your threads. Not sure if I missed this or not but I'm starting DIY ebb n flo using dyna gro grow , bloom, proteck. Can you help me out on a feeding schedule? I know it varies with strain to strain just need some base number to go off of and if I c it's on the high side ill make adjustments. My clones were started on Rockwell cubes and are now in 1 gal pots. Using tap water starting at 200ppm 8.0 ph. Currently under fluorescent for 2 week veg then to flower under 600whps. Currently top feeding as I'm not sure how many gal of a Rez I need. I was going to use a 30 gal barrel but it limits my height availability. Would I be ok with say a 20 gal Rubbermaid from homedepot?
Maybe. The size of your res is sort of dependent on the size of your flood table and the number of plants you're running.

what I mean for feeding schedule is for all stages of growth say for newly cut clones do u feed any or just plain phd water?
Rooted clones going into veg. Would I be okay starting at around 400ppm when my tap starts at 200? And progress from there? The ratio between grow/protect? No bloom?
in flower considering a two week veg I should be at around 500ppm or is that too high? 8-10week flower time. What should I be at around week 8? 900ppm? What ratio of bloom/grow/protect? Protect all the way through flower? I remember reading that you said that even though your plants aren't burning at say 1500ppm but they'll be much better off at 1000ppm( just an example) I want to feed as little as possible without seeing any deficiencies. Thank you for all your help
The quote you quoted in your post is my 'schedule' for flower. Cut that back to .7 EC for veg and don't use bloom. Simple stuff!
 

homebrewer

Well-Known Member
So you guys are using the Foliage Pro for flower rather than the actual Bloom formula?
I'm currently testing Foliage Pro in hydro but in promix, both Grow and Foliage pro are vastly superior to Bloom. Thus far, combos of Grow and Bloom in hydro work best for me, that could change soon though.
 

joe macclennan

Well-Known Member
so far I like 25/75 bloom/grow for first 4 wks of flower and the exact opposite for last 4 weeks. 1/2ml/gallon magpro throughout flower and 1ml/gallon protekt.final ec1.1 w/c02

I am trying a 50/50 blend of gro/fol.pro for veg. and 1ml/gallon protekt. no magpro final ec.9
 

bluefoodie

New Member
This is confusing...I read up to page 16 of this thread and jumped to the end here. Back then homebrewer you were saying a ratio of 1-3-2 for flower is good and thought that AN lagged because of high N and not enough P. That was 2 years ago. Now you're saying Foliage Pro is superior to Bloom (at least in Promix), and others are saying the same thing about FP.

FP is almost the complete opposite of Bloom in terms of N-P, so I'm surprised it does well in flower. What happened? High P in flower is the outdated way of thinking now?

BTW thanks HB for all your tests. I'm still a noob getting a feel for all the different nutrients out there and I've learned a lot from you already. Nice to know you're always refining your approach.
 

homebrewer

Well-Known Member
This is confusing...I read up to page 16 of this thread and jumped to the end here. Back then homebrewer you were saying a ratio of 1-3-2 for flower is good and thought that AN lagged because of high N and not enough P. That was 2 years ago. Now you're saying Foliage Pro is superior to Bloom (at least in Promix), and others are saying the same thing about FP.

FP is almost the complete opposite of Bloom in terms of N-P, so I'm surprised it does well in flower. What happened? High P in flower is the outdated way of thinking now?

BTW thanks HB for all your tests. I'm still a noob getting a feel for all the different nutrients out there and I've learned a lot from you already. Nice to know you're always refining your approach.
Hydro and 'dirt' seem to behave differently as my promix girls need more N to stay green as compared to my plants in hydro. Yes, a couple years ago I was saying 1-3-2 was 'ideal' for hydro and to this date, I've not found a ratio that surpasses the results I get when feeding around a 1-3-2. But just because that ratio 'worked' for me back then doesn't mean it's the best approach and I'm always tweaking what I do to find the BEST way to do things. I'm in the middle of some stuff right now for hydro which should clear some things up.

Connoisseur's higher amount of N wasn't the issue, I believe it's the cheap ingredients they used to supply nitrogen; urea and other water soluble nitrogen. It probably does OK in dirt/coco/promix but then again, I'd bet my first born on it still being expensive, overly-complicated to use, and under-preforming as compared to professional-grade plant foods with decades more history like Jacks or DynaGro. In my professional opinion, ditch any plant food with a colorful label and a high price tag. Those foods are made for kids who have never gardened before.
 

bluefoodie

New Member
Sounds good HB, looking forward to those results! Another question...do I need to add Mag-Pro or Pro-Tekt to regular waterings (with RO water)?
 

drekoushranada

Well-Known Member
The grow formula seems to be a lot more "potent" than the bloom formula. I am going to have to give the Foliage Pro a try for sure.
 

trophy1

Well-Known Member
The grow formula seems to be a lot more "potent" than the bloom formula. I am going to have to give the Foliage Pro a try for sure.
I agree with you, the Grow makes a good base nutrient for flower. It is not good for veg, if you want to run dyna-gro then go with something else for veg, maybe the foilage pro. I didn't get to try foilage pro, my local shop only carries the grow and the bloom. I had to supplement the grow with a high nitrogen nute early in flower to prevent early yellowing.

In the last part of flower I used a bloom/ grow mix, slowly weaning off the grow.

My overall impression was dyna-gro can be a soild nute program but wasn;t blown away by it, I have switched back to Sensi Grow and Bloom, I felt I had better results with Sensi.

I rate myself at the intermediate level as far as grow skills are concerned, and was not being super picky about keeping stats, so take my opinion with a grain of salt.

Price wise DG is definitely very well priced, but I see Sensi as fairly priced also, I don't see Connoisseur as being worth the extra money. I'm not big on extra enhancers, I use cal-mag and overdrive/Big Bud. I usually don't add big bud till a few weeks in and Overdrive the last couple weeks before the final week when I use just a light bloom solution (400 ppm) to finish.
 
Top