WOW, I am so confused, maybe it’s the smoke. I have thought of using both of these products, but for various reasons I never actually have. Maybe it’s because of discussions like this. Way too much information and differing points of view, all of which seem to be valid. I have been using a home made mix. I stole this recipe (or most of it from a post a few years ago), I deleted some hard to find or what I felt weren’t needed additives. Ever since I have never had a soil related issue, take a look at it and see what you think?
4 gal local soil (from summer garden- sterilized)
4 gal compost (roughly 75% plant / 25% manure)
4 gal perlite
3 gal sphagnum moss
1 gal worm castings
2 cup bat guano (11-4-1)
1-3/4 cup greensand (0-.15-.6) (can be hard to find)
1 cup bone meal (6-12-0)
3/4 cup kelp meal
1/2 cup dry molasses
1/2 cup lime
Mix in a large trash can, add water, and stir daily. I like to wait about two weeks to allow a true mixture of all components. For me this makes enough soil for 2-3 cycles. The stored soil seems just as good as freshly mixed, just seal up the container.