for all ya disbelievers there is plenty of grows on icmag that use CMH and have fantastic results. the proof is in the pudding now go find the pudding. from my research ive concluded that...
-CMH gives a very slight less yield compared to HPS
-CMH puts out slightly less heat, but the big factor is that the way a CMH bulb is designed the heat tends to flow up through the top of the bulb more so than an HPS, therefore less heat is pushed downwards towards your plants.
-CMH gives plants full spec at high intensity allowing the plant to use light where its needed when its needed instead of being forced to work with what its got (HPS). because of this the plant looks and smokes more like outdoor weed, which i think is always a better smoke. the plant is probably more potent although i have not seen numbers for that statement. because of full SPD the plant is more floral smelling. MMMMM
-buds are leafier because of added blue light
this is all based off observations that ive made from following CMH grows, for the past year or so.
this is not to say HPS does not have its place in growing. the yellow-orange spike HPS has is great for flowering plants, but from what ive seen if i had to choose one bulb CMH wins hands down.
the best plants ive seen indoors were 1k HPS and 400w CMH under the same hood. WOW