you know ive heard the MH get hotter then HPS but i just got a 175 MH to go with my 150 HPS and side by side id say my HPS gets hotter even with glass over the HPS... So maybe its just me but id say HPS is hotter. 175 watt MH = 13-15,000 lumen 150 watt HPS = 17-20,000 lumen give or take.... so hps = more lumen = more heat...