Michigan Medical Marijuana Live, Interactive Statistics

Do you think the statistics reported by the state are accurate?


  • Total voters
    6

Dr. Bob

Well-Known Member
http://www.denalihealthcaremi.com/michigan-medical-marijuana-statistics/

Independent interactive statistics on the MMMA

This is a project we put together- still adding data but the largest sampling of Michigan Medical Marijuana patients not controlled by the state. Just a little bonus to the community. Interesting to see the difference between what the state reports and what we see.

Once all the data is in, the statistics will be updated live. This is already the largest collection of data outside the state controlled database and should be done in a week. There are already several thousand data points. Patients are reported by age, zip code and condition. There is no patient identifiable information in database, just basic demographics.

Key features-
  • Average age is in the 45-54 age group, not 24 as the state reports.
  • Differences between the percentages for each condition between our data and the state data (PTSD is underreported by the state, so is cancer and several other conditions).
  • Age distributions for each condition (not available on state data).
Dr. Bob
 
i like the patient age range pie chart, can you add a similar pie chart right next to it showing the demographics of michigan... i'm assuming it will show that the demographics of patients match that of the state.

"patient age range (all locations, all clinics)"
 
for ptsd what are you using as a metric for the cases in michigan?

would it be better to use this count?
https://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/magazine/issues/winter09/articles/winter09pg10-14.html
The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs estimates that PTSD afflicts:
Almost 31 percent of Vietnam veterans
As many as 10 percent of Gulf War (Desert Storm) veterans
11 percent of veterans of the war in Afghanistan
20 percent of Iraqi war veterans


theres also some studies done on fostered children who end up having ptsd in adulthood.
"Foster children are twice as likely as U.S. war vets to be afflicted with Stress Disorder"
http://www.michigancasa.org/uploads/1/6/4/6/16460156/psychological_needs_of_traumatized_children.pdf

many rape victims have to deal with ptsd as well, how many rapes per year in michigan?

its possible to do real counts of ptsd, we just have to identify and count the vulnerable populations and refer to the medical studies to find the numbers.
 
where do you get the average mmma age reported by the state?

the only thing i see about average age is your testimony on 4851
http://house.mi.gov/SessionDocs/2011-2012/Testimony/Committee14-3-7-2012-1.pdf

i remember there was maybe a senator or something who claimed the average age was 25 in a newspaper article, but somehow i doubt that is the official state statistic. LARA has done its best to hide any and all information about the program anyway.
 
Last edited:
for ptsd what are you using as a metric for the cases in michigan?

would it be better to use this count?
https://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/magazine/issues/winter09/articles/winter09pg10-14.html
The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs estimates that PTSD afflicts:
Almost 31 percent of Vietnam veterans
As many as 10 percent of Gulf War (Desert Storm) veterans
11 percent of veterans of the war in Afghanistan
20 percent of Iraqi war veterans


theres also some studies done on fostered children who end up having ptsd in adulthood.
"Foster children are twice as likely as U.S. war vets to be afflicted with Stress Disorder"
http://www.michigancasa.org/uploads/1/6/4/6/16460156/psychological_needs_of_traumatized_children.pdf

many rape victims have to deal with ptsd as well, how many rapes per year in michigan?

its possible to do real counts of ptsd, we just have to identify and count the vulnerable populations and refer to the medical studies to find the numbers.

Let's not forget Legal Abuse Syndrome and the fact that it, like the justice system in general, threatens the well being of every patient and caregiver. I've seen far too many people changed by what had occurred in courtrooms, just like I've witnessed soldiers changed by war.

 
Those are some very interesting ideas.

As for the average age of the patients, Schuette and like are fond of saying 'the average mmj patient is an 18 year old with a hang nail'. As recently as April of last year at the annual meeting of the American Society of Addiction Medicine in Austin, TX the speakers quoted the state as saying that the average age of medical marijuana patients in Michigan was 24, and that more than 95% got their cards for pain. It resulted in laughter from the audience and pissed me off royally, because I know better. I designed this page to prove it based on our database.

The purpose of the page is to provide patients and the news media with an alternative and independent source of information about the patient of the MMMA. Most are shocked to hear our average patient is 51.

Here is an article I wrote a couple of years ago about the underrepresentation of certain groups in the MMMA....

http://www.denalihealthcaremi.com/the-forgotten-medical-marijuana-patients/

In it I compare the percentage of AIDS patients in the program as reported by the state vs the number of AIDS patients in Michigan. Same with pain and cancer, and discuss some of the reasons they are not involved in the program.

Note too, that in our practice, we will not certify a patient for PTSD unless they have documentation of a formal diagnosis from a mental health professional and are in treatment. Yet still our rate is 8 times the reported rate from the state. Our rate of cancer patients, though still small, is 1.5 times the rate reported by the state. We need to direct our efforts to getting the word about mmj into those communities.

Dr. Bob
 
for ptsd what are you using as a metric for the cases in michigan?

would it be better to use this count?
https://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/magazine/issues/winter09/articles/winter09pg10-14.html
The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs estimates that PTSD afflicts:
Almost 31 percent of Vietnam veterans
As many as 10 percent of Gulf War (Desert Storm) veterans
11 percent of veterans of the war in Afghanistan
20 percent of Iraqi war veterans


theres also some studies done on fostered children who end up having ptsd in adulthood.
"Foster children are twice as likely as U.S. war vets to be afflicted with Stress Disorder"
http://www.michigancasa.org/uploads/1/6/4/6/16460156/psychological_needs_of_traumatized_children.pdf

many rape victims have to deal with ptsd as well, how many rapes per year in michigan?

its possible to do real counts of ptsd, we just have to identify and count the vulnerable populations and refer to the medical studies to find the numbers.

Nice information, our metric that we are using is the actual number of certifications for PTSD since we began using MichiganMarijuanaForms.com to create and document our certification. To date, the largest paper written on the demographics of medical marijuana patients (from a group of 7 offices in California in 2010 or so) had data on 1900 patients. We currently have data on over 5000. We are entering the last of the data into the stats page and then I'll be writing a paper for publication.

We are already seeing changes. When the state first started reporting % for each condition, I reviewed it and found the numbers added up to 103% (they double counted HIV and wasting). This showed they were only counting one condition per patient, and given a choice of a patient with cancer and nausea, which one do you think they put in their stats? yeah nausea because they wanted to minimize the program. I called them out on it with the Forgotten Patients article.

Now they actually are reporting better numbers and multiple conditions per patient, but it is good to do a head to head comparison with MY numbers to see if they are being honest.

Dr. Bob
 
Last edited:
The Health Professions Licensing Division in the Bureau of Health Care Services at the Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs has not issued any statistics on the average age of the patients licensed under the michigan medical marihuana program.

to my knowledge.

schuette? random police sending letters to the editors of local papers? sure they may have made up some statistics. but the state of michigan has not issued any age statistics publically.

thanks for your statistics dr bob, it is important.
 
These are the latest (Jan 4, 2016) numbers from the state....

Name of Debilitating Condition

% of Patients Afflicted With Debilitating Condition*

page6image61824
page6image61984

Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS)

page6image64464
page6image64624

0.38%

Alzheimers

page6image67120
page6image67280

0.05%

Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis

0.04%

page6image71656
page6image71816

Cachexia

0.83%

Cancer

4.47%

page6image76968
page6image77128

Crohn's disease

1.11%

Glaucoma

1.45%

Hepatitis C

1.60%

Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)

0.40%

page6image87480

Nail Patella

page6image88552

0.02%

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

2.97%

Seizures - Epilepsy

page6image94168
page6image94752
page6image94912

2.12%

Severe and Chronic pain

92.86%

Severe and Persistent Muscle Spasms

page6image99760
page6image100344
page6image100504

23.39%

Severe Nausea

8.95%

Wasting Syndrome


Link to report is

http://www.michigan.gov/documents/l...Statistical_Report_MCL_333.26426_510088_7.pdf
page6image104984
 
wow, thats the first time since the 2 year cards that LARA has reported the correct numbers. i'm amazed.

for the past 3 years they have only reported the cards issued during the 1 year.
which means with two year cards, you'll get a bunch of people registering only once per two years.
thus the counts in LARA stats were only half of the total.

thats why all of the newspapers said "patient drop in medical marijuana" , remember?
 
Yes, they were not counting the carry over from the previous year.

Originally the program was run by a former deputy that I suspect hated medical marijuana. That is why the cards took 8-12 months to be issued. A new guy took over a couple of years ago. I don't know his feelings on cannabis, but I do know he takes his job very seriously and works hard to do a good job. We are getting better stats, the cards are coming out, and overall things are a lot smoother.

Dr. Bob
 
Ok the comparisons have been updated to reflect the latest state data. Data entry is 2/3 completed.
 
i like the patient age range pie chart, can you add a similar pie chart right next to it showing the demographics of michigan... i'm assuming it will show that the demographics of patients match that of the state.

"patient age range (all locations, all clinics)"
that is an idea, I'll find some data and pass it along.

Dr. Bob
 
Back
Top