Yes - Go mixed specrtum at the 3:1 ratio you've been talking about, especially with CFL's.
I'm vegging under a 3:1 6500k & 2700k ratio @ about 150W/plant, I couldn't be happier about the results.
Flower, I broke down and got a 600W HPS ($182, to my door), because I wasn't all that happy with the density of my buds under CFL.
If you do go HID, a word of caution - Those lamps get fucking hot, so make sure they're secured properly(can't fall), and not near any combustible surfaces (drapes, paper etc).