Once and for all.. L.E.D or H.I.D ??!

ttystikk

Well-Known Member
I went all LED years ago. Less heat, no lamp replacements, lower energy bills, strong growth, amazing frost.

HID still works, kinda like your old '66 hemi powered 'Cuda; it will still get you there, it just takes a lot more gas and maintenance.
 

Flowki

Well-Known Member
Where have you seen a better overall quality in new tech led is better then hid bud. Ive noticed the opposite.
That's too vague for me to even try and answer. I don't think it's worth getting into all the details of why you could have drawn that conclusion, unless you are genuinely interested for us both to elaborate.
 

hillbill

Well-Known Member
I went all LED years ago. Less heat, no lamp replacements, lower energy bills, strong growth, amazing frost.

HID still works, kinda like your old '66 hemi powered 'Cuda; it will still get you there, it just takes a lot more gas and maintenance.
Where would one find a '66 Hemi 'Cuda?
 

Kingrow1

Well-Known Member
You can tell who the led trollers are on this site, never objective, always putting others down, never want to discuss light spectrum or ppfd even though they say it every other sentence.

What a bunch of tools, as soon as you say "led is better" you should note that most of us who arent here to troll think your a 'TOOL'.

Not my type of member sorry and others shouldnt allow them in here ruining what use to be a cool infomational site.... Sad :-(
 

Couch_Lock

Well-Known Member
You can tell who the led trollers are on this site, never objective, always putting others down, never want to discuss light spectrum or ppfd even though they say it every other sentence.

What a bunch of tools, as soon as you say "led is better" you should note that most of us who arent here to troll think your a 'TOOL'.

Not my type of member sorry and others shouldnt allow them in here ruining what use to be a cool infomational site.... Sad :-(
All forums have fanboys, just be glad you aren't one of em. I put zero stock in what the QB fan club says.
 

Kingrow1

Well-Known Member
60+ posts later

are we any closer to once and for all?
Its never going to be once and for all, either you belive the site who have given an objective run down of lights ppfd and spectrum or you believe the trolls who only have one answer which is 'led is the best at everything'.....

Only a dumbass would not see the answer, sorry are you still asking.....?

:-)
 

Kingrow1

Well-Known Member
All forums have fanboys, just be glad you aren't one of em. I put zero stock in what the QB fan club says.
I didnt and pointed out where ppfd is vastly flawed and how they do not know what perfect spectrum is for any plant pkus their spectrum is so full of holes it makes hid look like the future not led.

Suffice to say they only give one answer and discussion with them is useless, reminds me of those egotistical borg from star trek :-)
 

diggs99

Well-Known Member
Its never going to be once and for all, either you belive the site who have given an objective run down of lights ppfd and spectrum or you believe the trolls who only have one answer which is 'led is the best at everything'.....

Only a dumbass would not see the answer, sorry are you still asking.....?

:-)

Ya my first post in this thread could have ended it. I was the first to reply to op and predicted the end result lol

Here we are, 70-80 posts in and still going lol
 

Kingrow1

Well-Known Member
ppfd, lumens, par.......abstract terms if you aren't a scientist.

Look at the plants, I say. Give them what they need (water Ph'd in soil Ph'd) with lots of light. If ya see a deficiency fix it.

Anything else spouted is bullshit.

Science destroyed their claims, their recent run a hps in cold country and led in a hot one is just a rehash of their old claims that led light made no heat and crap.

Merely i could run any light in any country and these fools are amature tools with no point or good info :-)
 

Couch_Lock

Well-Known Member
So many websites give contrary opinions.......Believe your eyes, what you can see. If you aren't attentive to your plants you won't get the best results you can. I've seen a basement grow with a hundred LED lightbulbs, no nutes given AT ALL and the guy got $180 a zip........Was better then mids, but not quite medical grade.
 

Kingrow1

Well-Known Member
Top