If taking in the whole plant it tells me there is a problem. If they die off is it a huge problem? No, not most of the time but if you look at ops plants there are issues, that's what this thread is about. If mine die then I typically have a problem as they tend to stay green on healthy plants.
Never said or alluded the op's plants were healthy.
Ok I will but you'll have to remind me lol. But yup after a few weeks I pay no never mind if they aren't there, but yup they typically are. I just know that if my plants have any dificiencies or stress the cotyledons suffer, if I don't they stay healthy and green. I've always kind of wondered why it's just accepted that they fall off when mine don't lol. I'm sure I'm not the only one or we better call the Catholic Church because I'll be the first to admit I'm not a, write a book, super grower, although I should be with all the years I've done this
.
Nope. You're taking everything I said and twisting it. It IS normal for plants to lose cotyledons. Simple fact. My advice was not ignore the issues of yellowing, my advice was to leave his plant alone and observe if it got worse without intervention. Sorry if it was misconstrued. Again, several people here agree with what I said. The issue here is not whether I am wrong, have a different view of yours, or gave bad advice, the issue is the fact that because I am new to MJ and indoor you took that to mean I am new to plants and have no right to post opinions, which is untrue. If I was wrong, being dismissive and arrogant, which is what you continue to be toward anyone on this thread with a different view than yours, is no way to help anyone learn.
You basically told the guy his plants were normal and nothing to worry about. No misconstruing of anything. Quick answer to OP without all the other bullshit, your plants are not well and yes you need to change things, be it watering or something else.
Right, my bad. Apart from being the best grower on RIU you obviously have a PhD in English literature and have obviously never misunderstood anyone.
I'm not claiming to be an expert. I've had my fair share of mistakes and screw ups.Ok I will but you'll have to remind me lol. But yup after a few weeks I pay no never mind if they aren't there, but yup they typically are. I just know that if my plants have any dificiencies or stress the cotyledons suffer, if I don't they stay healthy and green. I've always kind of wondered why it's just accepted that they fall off when mine don't lol. I'm sure I'm not the only one or we better call the Catholic Church because I'll be the first to admit I'm not a, write a book, super grower, although I should be with all the years I've done this
Iam talking abt this one
I did pay much attention to them either until I got a chiller and started using bennies, I also dropped my floods to 2 times a day until roots were established and they started to stay green. So I can only assume that if the plant is happy they stay green. Last summer I watched the outdoor girls and the ones that I added tea to were green as well. But your right, after 4-5 weeks I stop looking but when I cut the last few runs they were still there and healthy. Also like I said I'm far from what I would consider a great grower either lol.
Thank you
.
Over watered.This was taken today...what do u guys think about the first set of leaves. it is turning pale and yellow..but new leaves are jst fine .what could be the reason...iam still using cfl because of the other two seedlings...can i use Mh for seedlings??
Thank you guys for your love..peace
View attachment 3926384 View attachment 3926392 View attachment 3926393 View attachment 3926396
View attachment 3926384 View attachment 3926392 View attachment 3926393 View attachment 3926396 View attachment 3926399