I started 2 seedlings in a cut off gallon jug. I planted both thinking one wouldn't sprout. They both sprouted and they are about 5 days old now. They are both on separate sides of the pot. How can I separate them both and transplant them?
This is not a bad suggestion. I'd let them grow 2 or 3 weeks to get a root system going then try to split them. I split a lot of house plants and outside ornamental flowers and use a long serrated knife, like a bread knife.
If it's regular seed, not feminized, odds are one is a male. You could wait till they show sex and then one if one shows balls cut it out.