TGA Strains Stable?

bluntmassa1

Well-Known Member
nirvana seeds are cheaper from attitude then direct from nirvana I'll let you do the math
A pack has ten seeds and retails for what, $100? (I think Ontario seedbank had these for $75 for a while). The seedbank is paying wholesale for them, which is probably only about half the retail, or possibly even a bit less.

Meanwhile, Sub still has to develop the lines, grow and maintain the plants, make the seeds and quality control them, pack them, ship them to the retailer (which may entail confiscation or other legal risk), market them, etc. I'm not privy to the details of his business, but I don't think he's doing all these things personally, meaning he has to pay others to do at least some of the work. If there is legal risk, the pay has to reflect it. Once you factor in all the expenses, I can see him only netting $10-15 a pack, at least in initial runs.

Personally, I've got no issue with the cost. The guy has to make a living and he can ask whatever he likes for his seeds. Ultimately he doesn't decide what they're worth, the market does. If he asks more than other seeds of the same quality, he's going to have very few buyers. If they don't deliver for some other reason, same thing.

My issue is that most of the TGA strains are non-stabilized polyhybrids. That's OK, in the sense that you certainly can get excellent and unique plants from these sorts of crosses. The problem is that you may have to wade through a lot of different plants to find the ones that really represent the best quality of the "strain" (and in this case the term "strain" is used loosely!). In other words, YOU'RE the one doing the selection, not the breeder. As a secondary issue, for genetic reasons "strains" like this typically CANNOT be entirely stabilized, and even crossing plants like this with themselves will throw off a wide variety of phenotypes.

Lets say I buy a pack of ten seeds. Just by chance 1-2 of them may not germinate or make it out of seedling stage. Out of the remaining eight or nine, lets say I get five females. (And I might even get less).

With only five females to select from, I "should" have a good shot of getting one that has that "killer" phenotype. But its a gamble; with only a few females in any pack and many possible genetic variations, any given pack simply may not contain any seeds that have that great phenotype. Now, if I had the financial ability to buy a few packs, and to grow out 5-10-20 plants at once, then do the selection to find an extra special "mother" plant for cloning, I would be assured of finding that great phenotype, but that's an expensive, and somewhat labor-intensive proposition just to find one plant. From a practical standpoint, it might be easier/cheaper for me to just locate an already selected clone.

What if I'm a small personal grower, and I want to start from seed each time? Not so good. I don't want to have to pay $100 for a roll of the dice every time I buy a pack of seeds.

What if I'm limited to only a small number of plants for space or legal reasons, and I'm already growing out two or three other "keepers"? Even if the money for the seeds is no object, if I can only grow a few plants at a time, finding that "keeper" plant may not be easy or practical, and I might be committing all my spare "slots" to plants that ultimately don't turn out to be all that interesting. Again, not so good.

So, to my way of thinking, with so much great genetics out there, if I'm going to be paying $100 for a pack of ten seeds, then I want ALL of them to be potentially excellent, or at least give me something I need that I can't find elsewhere.

If I can only count on maybe 1-2 of the seeds in the pack to be excellent, then ultimately I'm paying $50 or $100 *PER SEED*, PLUS my time and labor in doing the selection to find the good phenotypes, PLUS the opportunity cost of not growing something ELSE during that same time.

Not worth it to me.
 

Capt. Stickyfingers

Well-Known Member
yea I didn't know there were genes in the plant that knew whether it was groing in soil or hydro....HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA..OH THIS SHIT KILLS ME!
Hah, you like that eh? Pure comedy. Here's another one of Sub's fanboys talking the same shit.
yeah pretty much all will work in any enviroment but some are predispositioned to work better in super soil as some are better outdoor/in greenhouses/ indoor
There are absolutely strains that do better in diff mediums.

Some strains don't like hydro, just as some don't like super soil.

Look no further than the last episode of weed nerd if it's that big of a deal to you.

Ccoastal
Lol
 

Gamer621

Well-Known Member
I have also heard he is good about deleting any negative post online in his threads ha. Seems his seeds are more of a hassel than what it's worth.
Im waiting for sub to show up in this form and confirm that his strains are meant to be growin in supersoil haha
Deleteing negative posts? The man deletes posts that might be negative or might become negative to him or anything he is related to. The man is a complete nazi about it. He wouldn't give the light of day to this thread. He wont come here. He certainly won't try to defend himself or his strains. Why would he? He cannot. At least not with his real account.

Hey! Think we can promote a "Swerve vs Subcool eXtreme Hermie Seed Deathmatch"? Sponsored by Mountain Dew Red Alert of course.
 

T Ray

Well-Known Member
Deleteing negative posts? The man deletes posts that might be negative or might become negative to him or anything he is related to. The man is a complete nazi about it. He wouldn't give the light of day to this thread. He wont come here. He certainly won't try to defend himself or his strains. Why would he? He cannot. At least not with his real account.

Hey! Think we can promote a "Swerve vs Subcool eXtreme Hermie Seed Deathmatch"? Sponsored by Mountain Dew Red Alert of course.

It's funny how everyone says that all the negative shit is deleted and that he has tons of hermies. I grown about 30 or so TGA seeds in many varieties and I have had one full herm (culled) and one that showed Nanners 48 days (culled) in. I have actually posted both (one with pictures) on his forum and neither has been deleted nor contested by Sub. Oh also I believe Weezer just posted some nanners on a AO thread and are still up and uncontested.


https://www.rollitup.org/subcools-old-school-organics/501670-tga-qush-bubba-kush-x-4.html Post 40 Pheno #6

https://www.rollitup.org/subcools-old-school-organics/523270-tga-pre-98-bubba-kush-2.html Post 20


Now I do agree that getting nanner's late in flower can be bad, but when growing seeds shouldn't you be diligently looking for nanners since it's a unknown and you haven't ran it before? Even the best breeders have hermies/nanner throwers. I know for me, anytime I run something from seed I always check for nanners/herms. It's just common sense.

Anyone's genetics can herm. I was reading "the seed collectors thread" and Bodhi had a bunch herm, but I don't see anyone posting about his shit herming and honestly people were shocked and didn't want to believe it. Shit happens. You as a grower need to watch what you pop, and cull out the ones that don't make the cut. It's simple.

Oh and if you want to talk so much shit about Subcool having hermies, here's someone talking about probably the most respected breeder in the business having issues as well. It happens. You cull it and move on.

http://www.icmag.com/ic/showthread.php?t=227405


I'll take a couple hermies all day if it means at the end of the day that the selections I actually choose are dank as fuck. Which is the case with TGA genetics. Reward outweighs the risk for me.


T-Ray
 

Gamer621

Well-Known Member
Yes, Any plant can hermie. Agreed. What was your point? You seem to think 5 pages of this thread are all about how only subcools seeds hermie? We're picking on subcool genetics while all other breeder's genetics are just as flawed? Come on, Get a clue. We're jumping on his seed because his genetics are as stable as Charlie Sheen. While all people that kill are murderers, only some are serial killers. Subcool's genetics are a serial killer.

Just because sub allows a few hermie posts (POSTS, not threads) get through doesnt mean shit. The guy has a cow if you mention feminized seeds. As if femmed seeds somehow have anything to do with anything, Unless your a greedy breeder.

You clearly think this is a simple attack on subcool about things beyond his control that all breeders experience. Wrong. This is about subcool's genetics sucking. You cna do everything right and his shit seeds will hermie.

You clearly missed the point. Go read the last 5 pages and let me know when you find it.
 

TheMan13

Well-Known Member
Hey guys having hermied many good genetics myself, it is my understanding that stress is the #1 cause of hermies. A plants sole intent is to reproduce and fear of death by stress will cause plants to attempt reproduction on it's own.
For example, nanners are common on good plants left too long into flowering. The plant knows it faces death and makes a last ditch effort to reproduce.

Just my opinion, but I found it odd that in 7 pages of this thread no one has mentioned these facts of the matter.
 
Hey guys having hermied many good genetics myself, it is my understanding that stress is the #1 cause of hermies. A plants sole intent is to reproduce and fear of death by stress will cause plants to attempt reproduction on it's own.
For example, nanners are common on good plants left too long into flowering. The plant knows it faces death and makes a last ditch effort to reproduce.

Just my opinion, but I found it odd that in 7 pages of this thread no one has mentioned these facts of the matter.
I find it funny that this is your first and only post and you happened to start here. LMFAO

the charlie sheen comment by gamer was funny as hell to.
 

Gamer621

Well-Known Member
That is probably because we're not talking about stressing plants in any way causing hermies. We know that happens, or at least I hope anyone on here trying to sound intelligent knows that. We're taking about plants starting to hermi "just because", as it would appear. Stress also doesn't account for 8 of 10 seeds being male or 5 of 5.

But hey, You registered in July 2012 and have 1 post so I'm totally sure your not trolling.
 

Clankie

Well-Known Member
This is about subcool's genetics sucking. You can do everything right and his shit seeds will hermie.
From the description of Jack the Ripper Jack the Ripper is a "Pluton X Purple Haze X Lambsbread X NL X Jack Herer X Romulan X Cindy 99BCGA"

So, that's like 7 sets of genetics, most of which are already hybrids, in one strain. That he then breeds with other ridiculous polyhybrids. So the only thing I really have to say about the whole thing is that with genetics like that, herms shouldn't even be considered a surprising mutation. A surprising mutation would be if it started getting up and walking around on its own. TGA claims to be about the 'science of dank' but it is pretty obvious that they are the equivalent of a 7 year old playing with his first chemistry set, just mixing everything that came in the box. There may be a lot of good potential phenos in any TGA strain, but clearly the best result for their seeds is simply to find a good mother to cut clones from, which is my optimum result from all the TGA freebies that attitude threw at me last month. However, even a hobbyist breeder should have the common sense to avoid introducing that kind of crapshoot genetics into their breeding stock.

Even furthermore, with breeding polyhybrids like that, even his best work is really just the result of other breeders' work. Any jackass (like me!) can buy two packs of stable hybrid seed from two different breeders, and then cross them, and you know you'll get mostly good phenos. But more than taking credit for anything, you should be thanking the breeders of your parent stock, who did the actual work in this case.
 

T Ray

Well-Known Member
Yes, Any plant can hermie. Agreed. What was your point? You seem to think 5 pages of this thread are all about how only subcools seeds hermie? We're picking on subcool genetics while all other breeder's genetics are just as flawed? Come on, Get a clue. We're jumping on his seed because his genetics are as stable as Charlie Sheen. While all people that kill are murderers, only some are serial killers. Subcool's genetics are a serial killer.

Just because sub allows a few hermie posts (POSTS, not threads) get through doesnt mean shit. The guy has a cow if you mention feminized seeds. As if femmed seeds somehow have anything to do with anything, Unless your a greedy breeder.

You clearly think this is a simple attack on subcool about things beyond his control that all breeders experience. Wrong. This is about subcool's genetics sucking. You cna do everything right and his shit seeds will hermie.

You clearly missed the point. Go read the last 5 pages and let me know when you find it.
Clearly, I can see that you don't look at the results. I can also clearly see that you didn't see that I was responding to a specific quote (not the first five pages), hence the using "Reply WITH Quote" feature. How many TGA seeds have you personally grown out chief?

Go look at Matt Rize,T-Curtiss,Nugbuckets , Hovering , Ocanabis. Tell me they dont grow dank. You crack me up guy.

BTW Nugbuckets has got a chance at a HT cover growing some TGA Ace of Spades.

If TGA genetics suck so bad then how come person after person is showing pictures of dank ass TGA grown all the time?

Proofs in the pic's man. You don't just magically grow shit that looks like that. It's good genetics and growing skills.

T-Ray
 

bluntmassa1

Well-Known Member
whats up subcool ? you open a new account today?
Hey guys having hermied many good genetics myself, it is my understanding that stress is the #1 cause of hermies. A plants sole intent is to reproduce and fear of death by stress will cause plants to attempt reproduction on it's own.
For example, nanners are common on good plants left too long into flowering. The plant knows it faces death and makes a last ditch effort to reproduce.

Just my opinion, but I found it odd that in 7 pages of this thread no one has mentioned these facts of the matter.
 

Gamer621

Well-Known Member
Clearly, I can see that you don't look at the results. I can also clearly see that you didn't see that I was responding to a specific quote (not the first five pages), hence the using "Reply WITH Quote" feature. How many TGA seeds have you personally grown out chief?

Go look at Matt Rize,T-Curtiss,Nugbuckets , Hovering , Ocanabis. Tell me they dont grow dank. You crack me up guy.

BTW Nugbuckets has got a chance at a HT cover growing some TGA Ace of Spades.

If TGA genetics suck so bad then how come person after person is showing pictures of dank ass TGA grown all the time?

Proofs in the pic's man. You don't just magically grow shit that looks like that. It's good genetics and growing skills.

T-Ray
Talking to a brick wall. Done with you.
:wall:
 

Capt. Stickyfingers

Well-Known Member
Clearly, I can see that you don't look at the results. I can also clearly see that you didn't see that I was responding to a specific quote (not the first five pages), hence the using "Reply WITH Quote" feature. How many TGA seeds have you personally grown out chief?

Go look at Matt Rize,T-Curtiss,Nugbuckets , Hovering , Ocanabis. Tell me they dont grow dank. You crack me up guy.

BTW Nugbuckets has got a chance at a HT cover growing some TGA Ace of Spades.

If TGA genetics suck so bad then how come person after person is showing pictures of dank ass TGA grown all the time?

Proofs in the pic's man. You don't just magically grow shit that looks like that. It's good genetics and growing skills.

T-Ray
My Jilly Bean was beautiful and had really nice coloring, lots of dense buds, nice smell, but hermed and was mediocre smoke. Looks can be deceiving. That's why I don't buy strains solely based on pictures and high times covers. Matt knows Sub personally so there is going to be some bias there, and the other dudes get free shit from Sub so there is some bias there too. Might as well tell us what Subs mom thinks of him too. I can tell you out of everything I've grown and smoked myself and smoked from others, TGAs been some of the least potent shit and the herms just turned me off even more.
 

Jogro

Well-Known Member
nirvana seeds are cheaper from attitude then direct from nirvana I'll let you do the math
I don't undertstand this remark. What math are you talking about?

In *any* business, wholesalers invariably charge 100% full retail for their product if they sell to the general public.

They *have* to do that, otherwise, they'd be undercutting their own distributors. With their distributors unable to sell product at a profit, it hurts THEM.

From a business standpoint it comes down to margin vs volume. You get better margins selling directly the public, but less volume.

In this case specifically, because Attitude has a huge customer base, Nirvana *wants* to have its seeds carried by Attitude, and in fact, it probably sells many times as many seeds through Attitude than it does off its own website.


Originally Posted by Ccoastal

yeah pretty much all will work in any enviroment but some are predispositioned to work better in super soil as some are better outdoor/in greenhouses/ indoor
Looking at this comment in the best possible light, I'd agree that since Sub grows, breeds, and presumably selects all his lines in super-soil, all his plants should thrive in that medium.

To be clear here, the Super-soil is a highly enriched organic medium designed specifically for growing cannabis. Though different strains have *slightly* different needs for optimal growth, this particular mix by design has an abundance of all necessary nutrients, and pretty much any plant "should" do well in that medium.

But so long as their nutritional needs are met TGA plants should be able to do well in a variety of growing conditions. Having or not having supersoil shouldn't be the "make or break" factor in growing TGA plants (or any plants).
 

Jogro

Well-Known Member
If TGA genetics suck so bad then how come person after person is showing pictures of dank ass TGA grown all the time?
Two points, and they're important:

-How a bud LOOKS in pictures (particularly ones taken professionally, then selected for publication) and how it SMOKES are often different. With fundamentally good growing, and enough lighting, macro lenses, background, etc, you can make the buds from any plant look good. Kind of like how with enough makeup, lighting, angles, you can make almost anyone look interesting in a picture.

-I don't think anyone is saying that all the TGA plants are bad. The issue is that the lines aren't stabilized. Its easy to make great pictures if you're taking of them of that one great plant you've selected out of 25 planted seeds (or from a cutting that someone else has done the selection on already).

The issue/question is about how many seeds you have to grow out before you find a great plant to take the pictures of!
 

Omgwtfbbq Indicaman

Well-Known Member
nirvana seeds are cheaper from attitude then direct from nirvana I'll let you do the math
not wholesale.... nirvana seeds are 20% off if you get 5 at a time, so you can get 10 of any strain for close to 220 and they give you freebies and other shit, haven't ordered from them directly in a year or so, the prices might have risen though.
 

althor

Well-Known Member
The issue is basically TGA does the minimal amount of work and then wants top dollar for his product.
Its hard to justify. No wonder he hates feminized seeds, it would require MUCH more work than just leaving a male in the middle of a grow room with a bunch of clones to seed up.
 
Top