You are right, I am almost always in favor of higher efficiency over better spectrum, especially when it is a small difference in CRi. What I am saying is that IF a top bin 90 CRi was made available (as listed in the current CXB3070 and CXB3590 PDFs) and assuming they don't release new top bins for the 80 CRi, then technically the 90 CRi would be higher efficiency than the 90 CRi.
All that said, that may not reflect reality, it may be because of arbitrarily chosen bins listed in the PDF.
-In the past Cree released new top bins for the CXA3070. It used to be Z4, then they added AB, now they have added AD.
-In the past top bin CXAs never became available they were just on paper
-80 CRi phosphor is probably more efficient overall because it is closer to the blue of the original die. For example if the very best blues were used, the 90 CRi would not be the most efficient outcome in terms of photons, PAR W or lumens.
For example if you look at the CXB2530 the 3000K top bin 90 CRi is still 2 bins beneath the top bin 80 CRi until you go up to 4000K.
Sorry OP, just realized how far off track we got