kush groove
Active Member
While math might say you could replace a an HID with 1/2 the wattage in an LED panel, I've never seen any real world results using LED panels that showed they could produce anymore than maybe 30% in weight over HID watt for watt. I'll believe a 200w LED going at least as well as a 300w HID but 400w might be pushing it unless its of the highest quality LED panel. I will definitely save on cooling as my 395w panel doesn't put out enough heat to warm my bedroom so even in the summer the AC won't be needed for the light but just the heat from outside. I don't know how to figure it out for sure but if I had to guess I would say watt for watt my high quality LED panel puts out about 20% (or less) as much heat as my 400w HPS system did. I don't expect it to perform as well as 800w of HID but I do think it will do as well as 600w of HID atleast/ifonly because light production is spread out over a larger area than a single 600w HID bulb (and each led has is its own 90 degree lense which would work better than a big reflecting hood with a little bulb.
Your absolutely right coverage area and quantity of light sources has to be taken into consideration... I think 1 on 1 an LED is a much better buy, all factors considered
Imagine a 1000watt hps vs a 1000watt led.....Now that would be something to see