wow! i have the igs220 but i want the sentinel chhc-1 SO FREAKING Baddd...i have a few sentinel controllers and digital timers...i love those things...freaking bad ass.
In my humble opinion, when you said you seal up everything you get 92-95F or somewhere around there...that sounds fucking perfect just about to run that 1500 ppms
optimal co2 in normal air outside is around 300 ppms...this is why they tell you to run 1200ppms on your system and with the intake coming in from the outside it will add and give you 1500ppms total
As far as your ceiling question, im not 100% sure, but im sure there is a ceiling....and im thinking that would be around 2000-2500ppm....but like you said some growers claim success with that...but i think in order to benefit from 2000ppms you need to have everything right especially temps. This is another reason why I dont think its worth the cost of wasting gas nor do i think you 'll see any more benefit from using the 2000ppms as opposed to the 1500ppms...but then again i could be wrong. Once you supply it with that many ppms of co2 you have to make sure you are feeding more, they have adequate lighting to be able to digest all the co2 in photosynthesis process.
I would run cycles of 1500ppms....let the plants soak it up for 30 mins to 1hr with the exhaust turned off, while leaving the intake turned ON. Then i would cycle the old used up co2ish air out (exhaust on) and refresh with more co2.
its always trial in error. The key is dialing it for your specified op.
Hope that helps